Staff Report | Editorial

A long time coming

It took nine years, but Michigan finally is in tune with the 49 other states.

The U.S. Supreme Court declined on Monday to hear the Michigan High School Athletic Association’s lone remaining appeal, forcing Michigan to move its high school volleyball season to the fall and schedule both girls’ and boys’ basketball in the winter, among other changes.

Not only is this decision groundbreaking for the advancement of Title IX, but it also means the CMU volleyball team, and other Michigan collegiate volleyball teams, will no longer have to recruit year-round.

This new rule, which will take place next year, has been a long time coming for Michigan high schools because it further strengthens the idea that boys’ and girls’ sports should be equal.

Girls’ and boys’ basketball teams get to play at the same time of year, and volleyball, commonly an all-girls sport, becomes the female counterpart to football, commonly an all-boys sport, during the fall.

This is the way it should be because girls’ and boys’ sports should be equal. This is the best way to accomplish that.

But where this decision comes into effect most at the Michigan collegiate level is when it comes to volleyball recruiting.

Since the high school volleyball season runs during the winter, it’s been easy for CMU coach Erik Olson and other in-state college volleyball coaches to recruit because they could recruit in January, when only Michigan high schools were competing. The college volleyball season runs from August through November, meaning once the season is over, scouts can watch high school volleyball players live.

The Supreme Court’s decision, however, forces Olson to recruit high schools in Michigan when every other state is competing as well.

It wouldn’t make sense to exclude Michigan from paying federal taxes or from adhering to the U.S. Constitution, so why allow it to schedule its high school sports differently? Obviously that’s a broad comparison, but the principle is there.

It’s just a shame it took nine years for the decision to be made.

There shouldn’t be too much fallout when this takes effect. Olson used to coach at Miami University, so he is familiar with the new way to recruit. It might take a year or two to get adjusted, but in the long run, this is only going to pay off for CMU and for Michigan high schools’ female athletes.

Naysayers of the decision may argue that it would diminish girls’ opportunity to gain exposure when paired with boys in the same season. But what’s the point of Title IX if boys’ and girls’ sports are recognized differently?

The Supreme Court made the right decision Monday.

And despite a year or two of adjustments, the switchover definitely will be for the better.

E-mail the author: defaultuser

Leave a Reply

Central Michigan Life encourages those who wish to leave comments, questions or feedback to do so here. Any posts with profanity, excessive defamation or other questionable language are subject to removal at the discretion of CM Life. Direct all questions regarding this policy to the Editor in Chief.

Follow Us

Advertise Here
Advertise Here

Facebook

What We're Reading

Philadelphia Inquirer

College students arrested for not paying tip

Brian Manzullo: Headline says it all. "You can't give us terrible, terrible service and expect a tip."  
TechCrunch

Paul Carr Debates Jeff Jarvis About So-Called Citizen Journalists

Brian Manzullo: A debate on citizen journalism after the coverage from Fort Hood. Real good listen.  
The New York Times

Prosecutors Turn Tables on Student Journalists - NYTimes.com

David Veselenak: A class that has real-world implications is facing real-world problems. Lawyers for a man convicted from the work of the Medill Innocence Project at Northwestern University are asking for the syllabus, grades and e-mail messages between the students.  

See more recommended links!

  • Popular
  • Latest
  • Comments
  • Tags
  • Subscribe

Text Alerts

Phone number

Carrier

*Standard text messaging rates may apply from your carrier*