Home » Voices » Columns »

DOOLEY: Make smoking cost an arm and a lung

 

I have a $10 limit on my indiscriminate impulse purchasing.

This is the genius behind the clearance DVD box at the supermarket, and it’s the only explanation I can find for why I own a CD of t.A.T.u.’s classic single “All The Things You Said.”

My inability to recognize the difference between the impact $5 and $8 will have on my checking account makes me more than willing to hand over my debit card for a pack of cigarettes.

Cigarettes are the most vilified substance of the past 15 years, but they have done everything to earn that reputation. Still, it’s sort of strange that cigarettes are legal at all. This is where myself and plenty of other American smokers need the help of federal regulation.

The cigarette tax is hurting my wallet, but it’s not enough to help me quit on my own. For those of you who suggest I rely on sheer willpower to quit smoking, I recommend you see the damage I willingly inflict on myself at a brunch buffet. Yes, Mom, this is my fourth bacon plate. Happy Easter.

Cigarettes will make you sweaty, yellow toothed, yellow fingered and dead. They will also make you exceptionally poor. I would make a more effective athlete on a Hoveround scootercart after the chimney session I have put my lungs through over the past six months.

Though I have no problem flashing my debit card for anything less than $10, anything over $25 gives me instant pause. This threshold is rarely crossed, except in cases of cable bills, celebratory bar tabs or clearance soccer jerseys. I am an exceptionally unthrifty cheap person; like many of my friends I would much rather buy ten $5 things in a day than a single $30 item.

So, please, take advantage of my poorly wired brain. If I am dumb enough to buy a pack of cigarettes for 30 bucks, then I will cough myself to sleep knowing I made a serious contribution to the local school district that day.

If the cost of cigarettes suddenly turns into the difference between eating dinner for an average worker instead of getting desert, then maybe we will finally face the end of smoking in this country.

At the very least, we will create an incredible revenue stream. The $25 cigarette tax might even make up for corporate loopholes and an illegal war in Iraq, but let’s not get greedy.

Yes, there is a solid argument to be made that incremental cigarette taxes are a regressive tax, that they target the poor. Anecdotally I can tell you truck drivers and machine shop workers are significantly more likely to smoke cigarettes than trust-fund kids who are just “really into yoga now.”

Broke college students, too, seem to never stop smoking.

So let’s stop the cruelty of 25 cent increases people on shoe-string budgets find a way to justify, and let’s just go for it: It’s time to make cigarettes an extravagant luxury.

 
 
  • Dahui1776

    If you raise the cigarette tax to an astronomical amount, all you will do is create a black market for smuggling. This is already happening in states like New York which has the highest cigarette tax in the country. If the product is so bad, why not just ban cigarettes? Oh yeah, we already tried that during the 1920′s with prohibition. Tell me, how did that turn out? Instead of telling people how to live their lives, why not give liberty a try?

  • Ben Steiner Brothers

    Because Jeebus says smoking is bad, listen in your heart to Jeebus!

  • Anonymous

    “The cigarette tax is hurting my wallet, but it’s not enough to help me
    quit on my own. For those of you who suggest I rely on sheer willpower
    to quit smoking, I recommend you see the damage I willingly inflict on
    myself at a brunch buffet. Yes, Mom, this is my fourth bacon plate.
    Happy Easter.”

    Wow.
    Way to go sir.

    You lack will power and therefore want to ……..what?
    Have the big omnipotent god/father figure of government come in and save you from yourself?

    But also myself from me.
    That’s just arrogant.

    Cigarette taxes will totally bail out the governmental/corporate
    entities and continue to fund illegal wars? and that’s good thing?
    You’re logic is insane.

    I don’t want to be saved from my cigarettes by going into debt.
    No government has the right to decide who lives or dies. (oh wait)

    No one has the right to tell me that I can’t kill myself in whatever fashion I want.
    Taxes only empower those who already have so much and then get to hide behind imaginary moral outreach programs like sin taxes. (They couldn’t care less)

    (written by a broke, educational trust-funded, vegetarian, college student – SMOKER)